Scientifically Sweet: Peanut Butter Cinnamon Sandwich Cookies

Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Peanut Butter Cinnamon Sandwich Cookies

Who doesn't like a sandwich cookie?

Most of us grew up with Oreos right?

Remember Fudgee-O's? Those are cool.

Later they stepped it up by putting double stuff inside of them, and around the holidays they like to dip the whole darn thing in white chocolate. Nuts.

Sandwich cookies are fun - two crisp cookies with a creamy filling. You can pull them apart and lick the middle until it's gone. You can dunk them in milk and let them get a bit soft before taking a bite.

Become a kid again and make some sandwich cookies in your own kitchen.

Maybe put some pigtails in your hair and smear red lipstick all over your face too. Or  not. Whatever.

These aren't your usual cookies though. I combined the flavours of cinnamon and peanut butter and surprised the crap out of myself. It's so good!

These little cookies bake up super crisp. I roll out the dough to 1/8-inch thickness and use a round cookie cutter with a diameter just shy of 2-inches to cut out little disks.

After baking them off and letting them cool completely, I spread a teaspoon of creamy peanut butter on the flat side of one cookie and gently press another one on top to make a little sandwich.


PS - my mom would call these "sangwich" cookies. Drives me nuts!

The low ratio of fat and relatively high ratio of sugar in this recipe keeps these cookies crisp.

Go be a kid. Have fun. Eat cookies and smile. Share them with your neighbours. Make them smile.

I like you.

Pin It


  1. Se ven estupendas! deliciosas!
    Saludos Da & Mer

  2. Peanut butter AND cinnamon? Looks fantastic!

  3. These look delicious, perfect little snack! LOVE the addition of cinnamon! :)

  4. These sound super yummy. I love that they have cinnamon.

  5. Yum! Sandwich cookies are awesome and I love the peanut butter and cinnamon combo. Yum!
    And how your mom would say it makes me laugh. Even though that drives me crazy too it reminds me of my sister in law saying words weird, haha.

  6. These look so awesome! I adore peanut butter flavored desserts...if only I could get my bf on board with them...

    - Maggie

  7. I love your photos! Especially that first one, beautiful photos to go with a beautiful recipe :) Sounds like a winner for sure, there are not enough super crisp cookies out there and that is definitely by texture of choice. Saved and just waiting to be made :)

  8. There's something about a childhood evoking dessert that makes it better than any other. Hands down. Remember when dessert was the pinnacle of happiness?

  9. yes! I love peanut butter and cinnamon...these sound like my perfect cookie!

  10. Just made these! SOOO DELICIOUS! I did not have enough time to chill the dough or roll it out. I ended up just rolling the dough into balls and squishing it down. They still worked well!


Subscribe via email